yunsheng

a great review of a great book

yunsheng

It is not my habit to read anything related to a book without reading the book first. It is partially out of spoiler alertness, partially out of the consideration that reading a book with a mind that is preempted by someone else's viewpoint might influence or even skew my understanding and interpretation of it. Sometimes, my uneasiness from reading something that leaks the content of a book or a film is so great that I would even drop the motivation to read the book or watch the movie in the first place. But this one is an exception.

I indeed hesitated a while before reading this review. But the fact that the novel itself is not on my current reading list attenuated my uneasiness to a large extent. Speculating that it is not always that bad to accept someone else's interpretation and insights on a book, just for their ideas' own right, without referring to the book, I clicked on the "read" button. After all, you can not read every book, no matter how good they are.      

To my total surprise and raptures, this review is so well written that I finished reading it in one sitting (OK, it is quite concise). Despite its brevity, this review is quite comprehensive in terms of its content: plot introduction, character analysis, emotion investment on the reviewer's side, news related to the book, etc.,basically everything a book review requires. Above all is the reviewer's personal emotion investment into the novel, making the essay less icily impersonal that features a journal article review, but more humanity imbued.

To my further astonishment is my learning that the reviewer is just a teenager who is seven years younger than me. Being able to write such an essay at such an age, the reviewer must be endowed with talent, equipped with diligence, and promised with prosperity.

2013-08-10
喜欢(5)
发布

回复(共8条)

  • yy
    yy
    good

    2023-05-12

  • 用户526198
    用户526198


    也许每个人心中都有一个风筝,无论它意味着什么,让我们勇敢地追。

    因为他不仅是卡勒德的阿米尔,也是你和我的阿米尔。

    2019-11-18

  • 二三
    二三
    这本书真的很经典,值得一读

    2019-06-23

  • 嗯⊙∀⊙!
    嗯⊙∀⊙!
    强烈推荐

    2019-02-28

  • 铭玲今
    铭玲今
    一直很喜欢这本书,很治愈

    2019-02-10

  • 用户498210
    用户498210
    nice

    2019-02-07

  • yunsheng
    yunsheng

    to Cindy小虫: yeah, she (ok, it's a she) has an edge over us in terms of language; and the glorious task of translating and disseminating Chinese literature falls on your shoulders!

    2013-08-12