Great Expectations--1. Help or not? (Chapter 1)

孙博

If you were Pip and met someone who really need your help but who might be a bad person, like the convict in Great Expectations, what would you do? Would you help him or not? 

2023-09-14

分享

喜欢(0)

回复

• 

  5
  I will choose to help him, because human nature is not bad, perhaps he is not guilty, it may be framed by people, in that era, capital is king, and saving a life is better than building a seven-level pagoda

  2023-12-26 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  何雅月
  If I were pip, I would not choose to help him because he needs help after he is a bad person before I help him, he may not know how to appreciate it

  2023-12-05 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  用户699698
  I will help him, because if I don't help him, I may be in danger, but after helping, I will stay away from him to be safe。

  2023-11-21 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 用户701290
  I will help him. Helping someone should be defined by the nature of their help, rather than a general definition of good or bad people. If your help will make the other person better, it should be helpful. In this book, Pip helped the criminal and provided him with food. Later in that chapter, Joe also recognized helping the criminal to prevent him from starving to death. I will hesitate whether bad people will continue to do evil with my help, but such a kind gesture is always good. As long as the direction I am helping is good and not helping the tyrant, then helping someone who truly needs my help is what I should do.

  2023-09-25 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 用户701290
  I will help him. Helping someone should be defined by the nature of their help, rather than a general definition of good or bad people. If your help will make the other person better, it should be helpful. In this book, Pip helped the criminal and provided him with food. Later in that chapter, Joe also recognized helping the criminal to prevent him from starving to death. I will hesitate. I have helped the bad person, and they may continue to do evil, but such a kind action is always good. As long as the direction I am helping is good and not aiding tyranny, then helping someone who truly needs my help is what I should do.

  2023-09-25 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 用户701290
  I will help him. Helping someone should be defined by the nature of their help, rather than a general definition of good or bad people. If your help will make the other person better, it should be helpful. In this book, Pip helped the criminal and provided him with food. Later in that chapter, Joe also recognized helping the criminal to prevent him from starving to death. I will hesitate. I have helped the bad person, and they may continue to do evil, but such a kind action is always good. As long as the direction I am helping is good and not aiding tyranny, then helping someone who truly needs my help is what I should do.

  2023-09-25 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  rong
  I'll help him, whether it's humanitarian or not

  2023-09-25 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  陈萍22应英1班
  I may choose to help him, because when I help him, he is a person who needs help.

  2023-09-24 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  胖猪的喵
  I will most likely choose to help him, he may be a bad person, but the criminal in the great expectations does not want to become a criminal at the beginning, people are not saints, to err, do their best to help others, and have a clear conscience.

  2023-09-20 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  孙博
  very good point!

  2023-09-18 刪除 喜欢(0)