A small discuss

刘青青

What do you think of Mr. Heathcliff？

2020-06-13

分享

喜欢(0)

回复

• 雾里云泽
  He is not only a cruel executioner, but also a prisoner of the soul. The past trauma has cast an invisible shackle and firmly imprisons him. As an abandoned baby adopted by the old manor, Heathcliff's arrival broke the inherent tranquility of Wuthering Heights. Hindley hated him and regarded him as a usurper of his father's feelings and his privileges; Linton, of noble birth, despised him and regarded him as an alien from the upper class. After the death of the old manor, Hindley deprived Heathcliff of all his rights and even more insulted him. Childhood was constantly denied, abandoned experience makes the idea of revenge rooted in his mind, the appearance of silence breeds a crazy toxin.

  2020-07-10 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 18054
  I agree

  2020-07-10 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 18054
  He is cold and callous.

  2020-07-10 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  刘青青
  yes,that's right.sometimes we have to change even if we won't feel happy

  2020-06-23 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  刘青青
  Agree，his emotions were poignant

  2020-06-23 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  乙宁
  Even if he finally becomes a "devil", is he really omnipotent?No.If he could, he would choose to have a safe life with Catherine and a happy family.In the face of oppression, he chose a person to go abroad and seek fortune.This is the only way for him to face the social oppression of class.He can't change his birth, only use wealth for ostensible class promotion.He tried to be a squire, but he couldn't really be a man of high social status.His humanity shows that he did not gain happiness after his revenge.On the contrary, he felt the condemnation of conscience.He didn't want to be the second Hindley.

  2020-06-16 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  乙宁
  Heathcliff seemed to be a vicious villain.He abused Isabella and Haraton and kidnapped little Catherine.He looked cold, cruel, obeying the law and morality.But when old Mr Earnshaw passed away, he comforted Catherine with heaven, and his love of her both reflect his kindness.

  2020-06-16 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  乙宁
  I think he is cold and callous, but he is sincere in his treatment of Catherine. He loves her. In his heart, too, there was great tenderness and great love.One's original intention may be good or bad.I'm more inclined to think that the unfair treatment he received later turned him into a bad guy.

  2020-06-13 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  纪星宇
  The Wuthering Heights represents his deep short love with Catherine. It's the only place that he once had true love. So I also think he is a tragic character.

  2020-06-13 刪除 喜欢(0)

• 

  纪星宇
  He is kind of a devil The whole street happened because his sincere love for Catherine. However they were forced to break up. It is kind of a revenge. Since Catherine passed away because there were not people taking care of when she was badly ill.

  2020-06-13 刪除 喜欢(0)